What is a Major Non Conformity?

A Major Nonconformity in an ISO 27001 audit refers to a significant failure to meet the requirements of the standard, which impacts the effectiveness of an organization’s Information Security Management System (ISMS) and its ability to achieve intended results. These are serious issues that require immediate corrective action and can prevent an organization from obtaining or maintaining ISO 27001 certification.

Characteristics of Major Nonconformities

1. Systemic Impact: They affect the overall capability of the ISMS to function effectively and achieve its objectives.
2. Significant Doubt: There is substantial doubt about whether effective process control is in place or whether specified requirements for products or services can be met.
3. Accumulation of Minor Issues: Multiple minor nonconformities related to a single process or issue may indicate a larger systemic failure, escalating them to a major nonconformity.
4. Mandatory Documentation Issues: The absence of required documentation, such as policies, risk assessments, or Statement of Applicability (SOA), is a common example.
5. Process Breakdown: A complete failure in implementing or maintaining key processes, such as internal audits, risk assessments, or management reviews.
6. Misuse of Certification Marks: Misleading customers by improperly using certification marks also constitutes a major nonconformity.

Examples of Major Nonconformities

- Failure to conduct mandatory internal audits or management reviews.
- Lack of evidence that security controls are implemented and maintained properly.
- Inadequate risk assessment or risk treatment processes.
- Absence or inconsistency in critical ISMS documentation (e.g., SOA).
- Employees not adhering to security procedures, leading to risks like data breaches.

Impact on Certification

If identified during an audit, major nonconformities can:

- Prevent certification for organizations seeking ISO 27001 compliance.
- Lead to suspension or withdrawal of existing certification if unresolved.

Corrective Actions

Organizations must take immediate corrective actions to address major nonconformities. This involves:

1. Identifying the root cause.
2. Implementing changes to eliminate the cause and prevent recurrence.
3. Reviewing the effectiveness of corrective actions.
4. Updating ISMS policies and processes as necessary.

Major nonconformities represent critical failures that compromise the ISMS's effectiveness and require urgent attention to maintain compliance with ISO 27001 standards.

Join our partners for your winning ISO20071 Lead Auditor. https://www.bcaa.uk/partners.html